Updates and Reflections on the dynamics of the residency Match as it progresses
Updated List of Virtual Open Houses: Match 2025
1. Your Personal Statement is Your Intellectual Autobiography
Your personal statement should closely reflect your personal intellectual journey and the experiences that shaped your desire to pursue medicine. It's about connecting your past, present, and future aspirations.
- Good Example: "Growing up, I was fascinated by how the body works. This curiosity deepened during my volunteer work at a clinic, where I witnessed the impact of healthcare on patients' lives." In three steps, the author explains how their mind was molded over the course of their life.
- Bad Example: "I’ve always wanted to be a doctor because I thought it was a good way to serve humanity." In this example, important intellectual connections are missing.
2. Be Honest—No Sugar Coating or Dishonesty
Your personal statement should reflect your genuine experiences, including the challenges you faced. Honesty shows self-awareness and maturity, while dishonesty can raise red flags.
- Good Example: "Balancing my studies with patient care during rotations was difficult, but it taught me the importance of time management."
- Bad Example: "I’ve never faced any challenges throughout medical school; everything was smooth sailing."
3. Avoid Discussing Mental Health Struggles
While it's important to acknowledge the challenges you've overcome, discussing ongoing mental health struggles can raise concerns about your ability to handle the rigors of residency.
- Good Example: "Medical school tested my resilience, and I learned to cope with stress through mindfulness and regular exercise."
- Bad Example: "I’ve struggled with anxiety throughout medical school, and it’s something I’m still trying to manage."
4. Refrain from Major Red Flags Like Mentioning Drug Use
Past or present drug use is a sensitive topic that can be viewed negatively. It’s best to avoid discussing it entirely in your personal statement.
- Good Example: "I’m committed to maintaining a healthy lifestyle, both physically and mentally."
- Bad Example: "I used to experiment with drugs in college, but I’ve moved past that phase now."
5. Make Your Experiences Personal, Not Based on Random Inspirations
Your experiences should be genuinely yours, not inspired by books or external sources that don’t directly connect with your journey into medicine.
- Good Example: "My passion for cardiology was sparked when my grandfather had a heart attack, and I saw the importance of timely medical intervention." I know this is cliche, but is a good example of how you should share your personal worldview in your personal statement.
- Bad Example:"I decided to pursue medicine after reading a book or watching a netflix show about the human body."
6. Avoid Strong Opinions on Irrelevant Topics
Your personal statement should focus on your journey in medicine. Avoid diving into strong opinions on unrelated topics, as it can distract from your narrative.
- Good Example: "Effective communication is crucial in patient care, and I strive to make every interaction clear and compassionate."
- Bad Example: "I have strong political views that often lead to debates with my colleagues."
7. Steer Clear of Obviously Fake or Embellished Stories
Program directors can spot a fake or overly embellished story from a mile away. Stick to authentic experiences that showcase your growth and commitment to medicine.
- Good Example: "My journey through medical school has been challenging but rewarding, and every experience has shaped me into a better future physician."
- Bad Example: "I once saved a patient’s life all by myself during my first week of rotations."
8. Don’t Write Cliché Stories About Witnessing Injustice
Avoid clichés like "I went to another country and saw poor people, so now I want to help them." Unless you took concrete action, these stories can come off as shallow or out of touch.
- Good Example: "During a medical mission trip, I was inspired by the community's resilience and motivated to make a lasting impact."
- Bad Example: "Seeing poverty on vacation made me want to change the world, but I didn’t know where to start."
9. Ask Yourself: Does Your PS Lead to More Questions Than Answers?
A good personal statement should provide a clear, cohesive narrative that fits well with your application. Avoid leaving the reader with more questions than answers.
- Good Example: "My experience in pediatrics has shown me the importance of preventive care, and I’m eager to explore this further in residency."
- Bad Example: "All my life I wanted to be a psychiatrist but here I am applying for IM to take good care of patients’ mental health."
10. Make Your PS a Coherent and Introspective Story
Your personal statement should read like the story of one individual—coherent and reflective of your understanding of your own journey and worldview.
- Good Example: "Growing up in a rural area, I saw the need for better healthcare, which has driven my commitment to serving underserved populations." All the examples should neatly point back to this commitment.
- Bad Example: "I’m passionate about medicine, and I also enjoy research, and traveling is something I love too." It is good to show your extracurricular side but don’t just throw everything randomly when they are not contributing to your intellectual journey.
11. Sob Stories Should Focus on Recovery, Not Just Sobness
If you share a sob story, it should highlight your resilience and recovery, not just the sobness. This shows your ability to overcome challenges and move forward.
- Good Example: "Losing my mother to cancer was devastating, but it strengthened my resolve to specialize in oncology and help others."
- Bad Example: "I’m still deeply saddened by my loss and find it hard to focus on anything else."
12. Make Your PS Interesting with Unique Details
Bring your personal statement to life by including vivid and interesting details that reflect your unique experiences and interests.
- Good Example: "I discovered a passion for medical illustration, which has helped me better understand anatomy and communicate complex ideas to patients."
- Bad Example: "I like to relax by listening to music in my free time."
13. Don’t Focus Too Much on the Cultural Aspect of Being a Doctor
While cultural awareness is important, avoid overemphasizing the "cultural" aspect of being a doctor, especially if your knowledge is mainly from TV shows or media.
- Good Example: "My diverse background allows me to connect with patients from various cultures, enhancing the care I provide."
- Bad Example: "Watching medical dramas like 'Grey’s Anatomy' taught me a lot about being a doctor."
14. Tie Your Personal Statement to Your CV
Where possible, align the experiences and themes in your personal statement with what’s on your CV. This creates a cohesive narrative across your application.
- Good Example: "My volunteer work in rural clinics aligns with my goal of serving underserved communities in my residency."
- Bad Example: "I have so many experiences, I’m not sure how they all connect."
15. Show an Insider Understanding of Residency and the US Healthcare System
Demonstrating a realistic understanding of residency and the healthcare system shows that you’ve done your research and are prepared for the challenges ahead.
- Good Example: "I’m aware of the challenges residents face, such as long hours and high patient loads, but I’m eager to learn and grow."
- Bad Example: "Residency sounds tough, but I’m sure I’ll be able to handle it."
16. Focus on Your Experience When Discussing Others’ Struggles
If you talk about your parents’ struggles, make sure to focus on how you experienced and were shaped by those struggles, rather than just recounting their difficulties.
- Good Example: "Watching my parents work tirelessly instilled in me a strong work ethic and a desire to give back to the community."
- Bad Example: "My parents had a tough life, so I want to make them proud."
17. Discuss What You’ll Do with Your Specialty, Not Just Why You Chose It
Instead of just explaining why you chose your specialty, talk about what you plan to do with it. This shows forward-thinking and a clear sense of direction.
- Good Example: "With a residency in internal medicine, I plan to focus on preventive care to help reduce chronic disease in underserved populations." It is not necessary to be dead sure about your fellowship plans but having some idea of your future self is a healthy sign.
- Bad Example: "I chose internal medicine because it seemed like a good fit."
18. Your PS should complement your CV
If your CV already emphasizes internal medicine, you don’t need to over-explain why you chose it. Conversely, if your CV has limited IM experience, use your PS to explain your interest.
- Good Example: "Given my extensive background in internal medicine, I’m excited to further develop my skills in this field during residency."
- Bad Example: "I’ve done some work in internal medicine, so I guess it makes sense."
Pro-tip: Authenticity is key!
Try Match Assistant: Now Booking
When navigating the NRMP match, applicants often strategically pair a highly competitive specialty with one or two less competitive fields. This approach allows them to maximize their chances of securing a residency position while still pursuing their desired specialty.
Competitive vs. Less Competitive Specialties
Dermatology and Internal Medicine
Dermatology is highly competitive, with a match rate of around 60-70% for USMDs. It requires high USMLE scores, extensive research, and strong letters of recommendation.
Internal Medicine (IM) serves as a good backup. It's less competitive, with a high match rate (~95% for USMDs) and offers opportunities to subspecialize later, including dermatology-related fields like rheumatology.
Orthopedic Surgery and General Surgery
Orthopedic Surgery is another competitive field, with a match rate of around 70-75% for USMDs. High Step scores and orthopedic-specific research are critical.
General Surgery can act as a backup, offering a broader surgical training path with a slightly higher match rate and fewer specific requirements. Many orthopedic surgeons also have general surgery experience.
Ophthalmology and Neurology
Ophthalmology has a competitive match process, often with an earlier match date, requiring high scores, research, and strong recommendations.
Neurology is less competitive, with a broader scope that includes neuro-ophthalmology as a subspecialty, making it a related and strategic backup choice.
Trends in Dual Applications
Dual applications are becoming more common as applicants seek to balance their aspirations with the realities of the competitive landscape. Applicants often choose related fields where skills and interests overlap, ensuring that even if they don't match into their top choice, they still enter a field they find fulfilling.
For example, someone interested in both Neurology and Radiology might apply to both, given the overlap in neuroimaging. Similarly, an applicant interested in Plastic Surgery might also apply to General Surgery, as it provides a foundational surgical education that can later lead to plastics through fellowship.
Try Match Assistant: Now Booking
To the Program Director,
I am writing this letter of recommendation for Dr. XYZ, who completed an observership under my supervision at the University of ABC. in month, year.
Dr. XYZ consistently displayed exceptional communication skills. He went above and beyond in his interactions with patients, demonstrating compassion and empathy towards those under his care. His willingness to assist patients in navigating their hospital experience did not go unnoticed, and I even received commendations from several patients who expressed their gratitude for his support. Dr. XYZ’s ability to establish rapport with patients is an asset that is integral to providing quality healthcare.
In addition to his interpersonal skills, Dr. XYZ exhibited a strong foundation of medical knowledge during his observership. He actively engaged in case discussions, where he consistently demonstrated the ability to identify clinical problems and formulate well-considered differential diagnoses. I was particularly impressed with his grasp of topics related to antiarrhythmia drugs and the treatment of atrial fibrillation. His knowledge and enthusiasm for learning were evident and contributed significantly to the educational atmosphere of our Program.
During our time together, I discussed various clinical guidelines with Dr. XYZ, such as the Rutherford classification for peripheral arterial diseases, the EHRA classification for atrial fibrillation, and the Canadian Cardiovascular Society grading of angina pectoris. He not only effectively assimilated this information but also displayed a deep comprehension of these guidelines. He readily responded to questions based on them and contributed valuable insights to our discussions. This ability to comprehend and apply complex medical guidelines highlights his desire for continuous learning and adaptability.
Furthermore, Dr. XYZ proved to be a friendly and cooperative team member. He established positive working relationships with the residents and colleagues with whom he interacted during his observership. His ability to collaborate effectively within a medical team is a valuable asset, where interdisciplinary cooperation is essential for optimal patient care.
Dr. XYZ maintained punctuality and professionalism throughout his rotation, which are crucial qualities for success in any medical setting. Additionally, I observed his dedication to his future career aspirations as he diligently studied for his Step 3 exam during his breaks at the clinic. This commitment to personal and professional development shows his strong work ethic and motivation to excel in the medical field.
Dr. XYZ’s exceptional communication skills, medical knowledge, teachability, interpersonal abilities, and strong work ethic make him a strong candidate for your internal medicine residency program.
If you have any questions or require further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Sincerely,
Try Match Assistant: Now Booking
For this year’s Internal Medicine residency match, candidates have 3 gold and 12 standard signals to indicate their program preferences. Here are a few strategies to maximize the impact of these signals:
1. Extremely Strategic Use of Gold Signals
Top-Choice Programs: Reserve gold signals for programs where you are genuinely most interested and that you believe would be an excellent fit. Since you only have three, they should be sent to programs where a gold signal could influence their decision to offer you an interview. We recommend one dream and two strongest connections to receive gold signals.
Programs Known for High Competition: If there’s a particularly competitive program you’re targeting (like a top-tier university hospital), a gold signal can help you stand out, especially if you have strong but not perfect credentials.
2. Geographic Preference Highlighting
Programs in Preferred Locations: Use standard signals for programs in regions where you strongly prefer to live and work. If you have ties to a certain area (family, support network), signaling those programs can strengthen your application by showing you’re likely to rank them highly.
3. Balancing Reach, Target, and Safety Programs
The Most Important Point >Balance Across Tiers: Allocate signals to a mix of reach (more competitive), target (where your profile aligns well), and safety programs (less competitive but strong fit). This ensures you’re signaling your interest broadly enough while still prioritizing key options.
4. Data-Driven Decisions
Review Past Match Outcomes: If available, use insights from previous matches to determine which programs value signals more. Programs with high competition and a track record of interviewing those who signal should be prioritized. Ask upper classmen how signals worked for them in the last year, that's your most important data point.
Try Match Assistant: Now Booking
Dual applying, which involves applying to more than one specialty, can be a strategic choice for candidates.
When Dual Applying Might Make Sense:
Uncertainty About Competitiveness in a Single Specialty: If a candidate is concerned about the competitiveness of their profile in Internal Medicine (IM) alone, they may apply to a less competitive specialty alongside IM to boost their chances of matching. Pediatrics in the recent past has shown signs of becoming more IMG friendly than IM with at least 10-20% higher match rate!
Interest in Overlapping Specialties: If a candidate has genuine interest in two related specialties (e.g., IM and Family Medicine), dual applying allows them to explore both while using signals effectively across multiple specialties. Believe us this is pretty much doable when planned in advance.
Maximizing Signal Usage: Dual applying gives candidates access to additional signals (3 gold and 12 standards for Internal Medicine, 5 for Peds, 5 for FM....). This can be a huge advantage if used strategically to increase the number of programs where they can express interest.
Potential Downsides:
Diluted Application Strategy: Applying to two specialties can lead to less focused applications, which might weaken an applicant’s perceived commitment to a specific specialty. Programs may view dual applying candidates as less dedicated, especially if this is evident in personal statements or during interviews. For example, Radiology & IM dual application can rule you out from higher tier IM programs if your application is too Radiology focused. But IMHO this is a small downside and the benefits outweigh harms.
Increased Application Costs and Effort: Dual applying requires more time, energy, and financial resources to craft convincing applications, write additional personal statements, and prepare for more interviews.
Pro-tip:
If you are open to dual applying, do it. Increased signal count will be a massive advantage.
Try Match Assistant: Now Booking
A cheating scandal involving international medical graduates (IMGs) with high USMLE scores has pretty much shaken trust in the residency selection process. While these scores have always been crucial, programs are now rethinking how much they rely on them. However, even with this shift, USMLE scores will still be super important.
Impact of the Scandal
The scandal showed that high scores alone don't always mean a candidate has strong clinical skills or integrity. As a result, some residency programs are looking beyond just numbers and considering other parts of an applicant's profile more carefully.
Scores Still Matter
Despite this, USMLE scores remain a key factor in getting noticed, especially for IMGs. They provide a quick and standardized way for programs to rank applicants. High scores are still essential, but now they need to be supported by other strong qualities.
The New Approach: Looking at the Whole Picture
Programs are starting to look at things like personal statements, letters of recommendation, and clinical experience to get a fuller picture of an applicant. They’re also more cautious about signs of dishonesty.
Pro-tip: Score is king, but not an undisputed one
Try Match Assistant: Now Booking